Policy impact is an integral part of the fabric of the Schulich School of Law. Our work is grounded in shaping public policy through interdisciplinary, collaborative research that has a positive, real-world impact beyond the law school. Today, we’re looking at Professor Richard Devlin’s work in legal ethics, and how it’s helping to shape the regulation of legal professionals in Canada.
Every individual and institution needs to be subject to mechanisms of accountability. Judges are no different. Professor Richard Devlin examined this issue as co-editorĚý˛ą˛Ô»ĺ co-author of the 2017 book Regulating Judges: Beyond Independence and Accountability, which provides a framework that identifies multiple variables for the assessment of an effective and legitimate judiciary.Â
“An important way to conduct that assessment is to consider different ways in which jurisdictions establish, support,Ěý˛ą˛Ô»ĺ regulate their judiciaries,” says Devlin, whose policy work has mostly focused on the regulation of the legal profession and the judiciary. His research attempts to hold those who exercise power to standards of accountability, transparency, and equality. “A thriving and mature democracy requires openness and innovation,Ěý˛ą˛Ô»ĺ academics hold the public trust to improve responsibleĚý˛ą˛Ô»ĺ responsive governance.”Â
In 2011, Devlin was the founding president of the Canadian Association of Legal Ethics/Association canadienne pour l’éthique juridique (CALE/ACEJ), where he currently chairs the board. Recently CALE/ACEJ has been making submissions to the Canadian Judicial Council on revisions to the Ethical Principles for Judges. One vital topic is whether this document should be given the status of an enforceable code of conduct or remain just a set of aspirational guidelines.Â
As faculty, we have the privilege and benefit of academic freedom, and this imposes a responsibility on us to promote the public interest in the regulation of Canadian judges and lawyers.
Another particularly hot topic is the issue of judges returning to practice after retirement, which has been catapulted into the limelight by the SNC-Lavalin affair. The issue at play is that while at one level they are retired and they should be free to do as they wish, another is that they are using the credential of being a judge to maximize their own and their clients’ self-interest.
Devlin’s research extends deeply into the Canadian legal profession’s codes of conduct. As a member of the Nova Scotia Barristers’ Society’s Code of Ethics Committee, he contributed to the Federation of Law Societies of Canada’s Model Code of Professional Conduct, as well as Nova Scotia’s Code.Â
±áľ±˛őĚý·É´Ç°ů°ěĚý·Éľ±łŮłó Professor Colin Jackson and Brent Cotter of the University of Saskatchewan’s College of Law on the duty of loyalty has influenced the Conflicts of Interest chapter of the NSBS’sĚý˛ą˛Ô»ĺ the Federation of Law Societies of Canada’s Codes of Conduct. He has also collaborated with Professors Jocelyn DownieĚý˛ą˛Ô»ĺ Sheila Wildeman on successfully arguing for changes to be made to the Duty to Report section of the Codes of Conduct to eliminate stigmatizing references to mental disability.
“As faculty, we have the privilege and benefit of academic freedom, and this imposes a responsibility on us to promote the public interest in the regulation of Canadian judges and lawyers,” says Devlin. “You fight the battles that you think you can win. There’s no predictability in progress, but you have to continue to engage with a sense of optimism.”
Recent News
- Dr. Sherry Pictou Receives Nova Scotia Human Rights Award
- Assistant Professor Suzie Dunn ft in "Grok’s AI‑generated sexualized images of girls and women underscore struggle to regulate social media"
- Assistant Professor Suzie Dunn ft in "Grok’s non‑consensual sexual images highlight gaps in Canada’s deepfake laws"
- Professor Emeritus Wayne MacKay ft in "Calls grow for stronger animal ownership laws in N.S. after deadly dog attack"
- Professor Michelle Williams and Assistant Professor Melisa Marsman ft in "Black Ģą˝AV academics want to create ethical research rules for African Nova Scotian communities"
- Professor Rob Currie ft in "RCMP investigating Ryan Wedding, aiming to lay charges in Canada"
- Professor Emeritus Wayne MacKay ft in "Why we still need ivory towers"
- Professor Emeritus Wayne MacKay ft in "A firm with a reputation for recommending deep cuts and layoffs has been hired as a consultant to review Nova Scotia’s universities"